web analytics
<

Take The Next Step, Carmelo

Photo by lukeroberts on Flickr

 

You might’ve seen this video of Kobe Bryant saying he’d like to play with Carmelo Anthony:

[flash http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7GK5sjh7zJw w=640 h=360]

The most interesting piece of information from that clip is that Kobe told Carmelo that if he was to come to L.A. he’d expect him to join him for 6:00 AM training sessions. Apparently he wasn’t thrilled with this idea, but can you imagine if this had happened? Put aside all the reasons why Bynum for Melo never made sense for the Lakers and think about what Anthony would be capable of if he was as obsessed with basketball as Bryant. Imagine a fully realized version of Melo, using his quickness, strength, and basketball IQ to be a top-notch defender. Those who are unfairly labeled as Carmelo haters are quick to say that he has the tools to develop on the defensive end in a good system — I’d say a system where Kobe Bryant is screaming at you for missing an assignment is the best kind.

Obviously, Carmelo Anthony is not going to play for the Lakers. He’s where he wanted to be, with a co-star in Amar’e Stoudemire who, despite showing good leadership qualities last season from the beginning of training camp, is not Kobe Bryant. And Bryant might be the only guy, save for Kevin Garnett, who I can picture chastising Anthony for playing lazy defense and forcing him into early-morning weightlifting sessions. Bringing Mike Woodson in should help, but I still have my doubts about a Mike D’Antoni team holding him accountable for his bad habits. This means if he’s going to have the career season we want from him, it’s on him. Fortunately, there’s precedent.

If Paul Pierce hasn’t been a leader in the past, then what makes them think he’ll become one this season? He’s saying all the right things now, but when they start to lose tough games, that’s when it’s going to start hitting the fan. They don’t want to wait too long to unload him, because when the player dictates a trade by complaining and setting a bad example, the team gets much less value in return–like Toronto did last year with Vince Carter.

Via Sport’s Illustrated’s Boston Celtics 2005-2006 Preview, 10/24/05

The above sounds pretty silly, given that it was written before the most statistically productive season of Paul Pierce’s career, the season where Bill Simmons says in The Book of Basketball, Celtics fans saw him become “everything we ever wanted.”

He wanted to be a Celtic. He wanted to be there when things turned around. He believed the Celtics were his team, for better or worse, that it was his personal responsibility to lead them. Everyone will remember his ‘08 season, but Pierce’s greatest season had already happened, the year he accepted the responsibility of a franchise player and killed himself every night. The groundwork for everything that happened afterward was laid then and there. Where did it come from? I couldn’t tell you. But it’s the reason a team like Denver ends up keeping ‘Melo for two extra years, because you never want a great player “getting it” as soon as he’s playing for someone else.

Via The Book of Basketball, p. 358

Pierce was 28 when he got it. Anthony is 27 and he clearly sees the Knicks as his team. It’s fantastic that he wants to be involved in off-court stuff, but to show that he’s worth completely gutting an exciting, promising team, he’s going to have to make the same on-court commitment that the veteran Pierce did. The season before Pierce’s career year ended with him yelling at Doc Rivers in a timeout during a blowout loss in Game 7 of the first round when Rivers was getting on him about defense. The end of Anthony’s first half-season with the Knicks wasn’t as dramatic, but it was disappointing – a first-round sweep at the hands of Pierce’s Celtics should be enough to motivate a man trying to lead his own championship contender. And while I submit that I have no idea if that series ever saw D’Antoni criticize Melo for his defensive focus, a couple of months prior his former coach said more than enough.

Approaching this (partial?) season, there’s already reason to be optimistic about Anthony – he’s healthy. Apparently his knee and elbow had been bothering him for the last seven years, and in May he finally had surgery on them. In addition to this, he’s slimmed down a bit. Despite my affinity for the pre-Melo Knicks and the post-Melo Nuggets and this scary Isiah Thomas stuff, I can get excited about seeing Amar’e and Melo work with a training camp under their belts. I’m not sure this team has the depth to properly compete against the upper echelon, but a true superstar turn from Anthony would certainly make that seem like a more realistic proposition. I can see it happening. Please don’t make me look stupid, Melo.

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Melo is my favorite player. So I would love for him to reach that next level that we know he is capable of. I had a feeling that this upcoming season he was going to bring it all out on the table and showcase what he has, because looking at interviews and him in general he seems to have a new mindset. Yet here we are with a shortened season, IF any season at all...

To clarify, not saying he doesn't work hard. Of course he works hard. Saying he's an unfocused/lazy defender and, while a legit star player, has the talent to get to another level. He can be more than an awesome scorer.

I'm a Melo fan, Want to see him kill it in NY. Think he's got something to prove. We'll see.

Carmelo may not shy from publicity, but that doesn't mean we know his whole lifestyle. Did he not have two surgeries when the summer began and no one knew about it until he stated it recently? So we can speculate all we want about his work ethics..but in reality none of us will know unless we are with the man 24/7

I doubt Carmelo will ever "get it". Everything he's done so far suggests that he is comfortable with the level of play he has shown so far.

If he really had a great work ethic, someone would have reported about it by now. He is never one to shy away from publicity, so it would be nearly impossible for him to have that kind of work ethic and keep it from being reported on. Maybe someone has, but I haven't read about it. Also, as Herbert said, he has the talent to be a top-notch defender, and for some reason he is one of the worst at his position on defense.

There is enough evidence to at least say that Anthony probably doesn't work as hard as he can.

give melo the teams teams kobe has had and history would be completely different. kobe is a fantastic top tier player no doubt, but he has had stacked teams under the most experienced coach in the history of the game. Give the Knicks Odom off the bench and Bynum at center and suddenly a dynasty. Kobe had the same thing, fisher instead of billups, pau instead of stat, and he had ron artest. Kobe will go down as one of the goat but he shouldn't compare himself to the less fortunate superstars. Michael didn't need a 95 million dollar team to win.

I think Fields, Melo, Amar'e and Shumpert could really turn into something nice. Of Course depth is needed, but NY could be solid soon.

Herbert isn't saying Melo doesn't "work hard". He's saying that possibly Melo needs a superior to, uh, light a fire under his butt-you know, to kick it into another gear. No doubt Melo works his butt off..but there's always more to be done.

Who says that Carmelo doesn't work hard? Do you know for sure? Maybe he didn't like the idea of waking up at 6:00 AM to workout because it was too early, not because he didn't want to bust it. You can get in the same work a bit later in the day with no loss of benefit.

I also think you're giving Kobe a bit too much credit for his potential leadership. Where was that kind of leadership when Odom was thought to be an underachiever as a Laker before Gasol arrived? More than Kobe, Carmelo could have used Phil Jackson to get him to take better shots and become a more well-rounded player.

Pierce and Carmelo are different players. They have similarities--big strong builds, all-around scoring games--but Pierce never had Carmelo's supreme confidence as a scorer. Carmelo has a pure scorer's mentality in the mold of Kobe; Pierce had a off button in his scoring that saw him disappear for stretches and made him want to be a role player. With Pierce's on-again, off-again scorer's mentality, Garnett's inclination to facilitate and Ray Allen's off the ball marksmanship, I had zero doubts they could fit together seamlessly.

Contrary to reputation, Pierce was a good defender from the moment he entered the league. He was never as unfocused a defender as Carmelo was. They're just different players.