Connor Huchton and Scott Leedy like to argue. Instead of shouting at each other on Twitter, they’ve decided to try something more constructive: an actual, semi-coherent email conversation. What you see below are the results.Â
Leedy: So, we’re almost 30 games into this bizarre season. LeBron James has been completely absurd, the Sixers and Pacers have surprised and sustained (for the most part), Jeremy Lin is currently saving the Knicks while trying to break the internet, everyone sucks at offense, and apparently Jamal Crawford is a better point guard than Raymond Felton. There’s so much to talk about, and it all feels so condensed. With that said, what has struck you the most so far this year? Has the product been poor like Charles Barkley said recently? Are you enjoying this season as much as the previous? More so?
Huchton: Last season was one of the greatest in NBA history. This season isn’t, but who cares? Basketball remains fun all the same. Scoring is down, but the play has improved lately, and the games are close. I’m just happy to watch all of it. And saying Jamal Crawford is a better point guard than Raymond Felton this season is like saying carrots taste better than onion soup. Not the best distinction. Also, I’m sure that a simple search of Internet.com will provide plenty about Jeremy Lin. This can be the one current Internet item that focuses on something else.
Leedy: I hate to keep talking about the Knicks, because right now they are the center of the sports universe, and New York already has an annoying superiority complex. However, I Â think the re-insertion of Carmelo Anthony and the likely addition of JR Smith are both things that need to be discussed. Now, we both know I have a borderline creepy infatuation with Smith and am a supporter of Carmelo Anthony, but I’m interested to see what you think about both players. Can Lin and Anthony work together? Is Melo going to be a victim of a tougher schedule coming back (versus the cake schedule that Lin faced)? Is Smith a good fit for this team? I think D’Antoni’s system is a great fit for Smith, but we’ll have to see how many possessions Smith kidnaps and how much of a liability he is defensively.
Huchton: I’m not a ‘fan’ of either player’s game. I don’t share your infatuation with offense-only scorers, but I think Anthony should fit pretty easily back into the fold. There isn’t a good reason for him to hijack the offense late in games, as Lin is more than capable of running an offense at any point in the game. As for the possible addition of Smith, I’m far more skeptical. The Knicks are a really fun team right now, and I’m not sure how he fits into the great chemistry the team currently possesses. Smith loves to take over an offense when he has the chance, for better or worse. I’m not sure the Knicks need that, but he’s likely a better, if higher usage option, than Bill Walker. So if he’s playing 15-20 minutes a game as the backup SF and getting a few minutes at shooting guard, that’s fine, and he likely helps the Knicks. But other than that, I’m not sure. But really, how much can we possibly talk about the Knicks? It’s a big league out there.
Leedy: I want to know when Carmelo Anthony became a “offense killer”. Pretty much all of his teams in Denver were well above the league average in offensive efficiency, and many years they were near the top. Does he have flaws? Yes, absolutely. He holds the ball too much at times and doesn’t probably create enough shots for teammates. However, I think we have evidence that if you build the right kind of offense around him, he can absolutely be the centerpiece of a potent attack. An issue arises once we place Carmelo in D’Antoni’s point guard-centric, free-flowing offensive that doesn’t exactly fit Carmelo’s perception of himself and his skills. I do believe that Carmelo has the necessary physical skills to make this work. It’s all about his willingness to change his approach.
As for Smith, I think D’Antoni is possibly the perfect coach for him in terms of offensive optimization. Smith is absolutely one of the best and most efficient shooters in this league, and D’Antoni offense has thrived on putting talented shooters in a position to knock down open shots. I also sort of scoff at this notion that “he’s a better Bill Walker”; Bill Walker is not very good, JR Smith can absolutely change and win games for you. Yes, he’s crazy, yes he can possibly wreak havoc on your chemistry, but from a pure talent standpoint, Smith and Bill Walker shouldn’t be in the same sentence.
As for the rest of the league, I’m feeling a little blue. The Blazers are in a state of panic that I’m not sure the situation warrants, and the Nuggets have succumbed to some unfortunate injuries, which has killed my, “the Nuggets are the greatest team of all time” thunder. So I’m content with focusing on the one thing that seems somewhat exciting in my NBA life.
Huchton: How do you feel about the changes in the All-Star Weekend format? I’m just waiting for them to bring in the “Low-Fat Milk Senior Challenge”. I’d love to see some former players, now of Social Security age, duke it out. Maybe Andre Miller will get an invite.
Leedy: Isn’t that what the Celebrity Game is at this point? Did you see Mitch Richmond last year? I’m not a huge fan of the dunk contest only having one round. I want as many chances to see awesome dunks as I can get. The fan vote thing is also kind of annoying, but that’s where everything is headed these days, so I’m not surprised. I think it would be way more interested if fans voted for playing time. Then we could somehow all vote that Kobe never plays, just to see how angry he gets. Or we could force the West to play all point guards, while the East played nothing but centers and forwards. The possibilities are endless. I do like the idea of drafting for the Rookie-Sophomore game, though I wish they did it at the event and picked two players to be captains. That way it would be way more interesting and awkward to see which guys were still there at the end of the draft.
Huchton: Yeah, an NHL-style format would be a good idea for the Rookie-Sophomore game. I also think it should be a requirement that one player is chosen every year from the worst team in basketball, just as a way of exciting the depressed fans of said team. Boris Diaw is ready for one last hurrah.
Leedy: That’s fine, but it should be the worst player from the worst team. Also, they should let the coach of the worst team coach in the all star game, as a reprieve of sorts, ya know?
Huchton: We always talk about the best and worst players in the league, but who’s the most average player in the NBA? This is an important question.
Leedy: I can tell you who the most “makes Scott want to jump through a window player” is: Wesley Matthews. As for the most average player in the NBA, it’s a tie between Markieff Morris and JJ Barea (according to PER). Courtney Lee is in the discussion, but you know who my choice is? Landry Fields. His PER is just below league average, but everything he does screams “average NBA player”. That’s no knock against Landry. I think he’s a fine rotation player, but basically he’s useful because he’s sort of average at everything.
Huchton: Those are all decent picks (except Fields, who is the greatest player in the history of the sport), but the only real answer here is Mr. Chris Wilcox, responsible for a 14.5 PER and completely acceptable post production. And isn’t that symbolic of this season? Perfectly acceptable, despite its comparably dilapidated form.














